Utah Department of Administrative Services

Division of Archives & Records Service

State Records Committee Appeal Decision Summaries, 1992-1994

The full decision and order is available by following the case number link. See also cases from 1995-1997, 1998-2000, 2001-2003, 2004-2006, 2007-2009, 2010-2012, and 2013-2015.

Search Decisions and Orders:

Case Number Case Title/Participants Records Sought Ruling
92-01 Salt Lake Tribune vs.
Utah Dept. of Transportation
Traffic accident database Appeal partially granted
92-02 Deseret News vs.
Utah Dept. of Public Safety,
Driver's License Division
Driving records [fee waiver] Appeal denied
93-01 Randy T. Nielsen vs.
Utah Dept. of Natural Resources
Hunting and fishing licenses Appeal granted
93-02 John Pace vs.
Dept. of Corrections
Monitoring of inmate phone calls Appeal granted
93-03 James N. Haywood vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Records relating to criminal charges Appeal denied
93-04 Sue Cherry vs.
Utah State University
Tenure retention records Appeal granted
93-05 Kenneth L. Gray vs.
Dept. of Human Resources
Records regarding a meeting Appeal denied
93-06 Equifax Services, Inc. vs.
Utah Dept. of Public Safety,
Driver's License Division
Drivers license database Appeal granted
93-07 ACLU vs.
O. Lane McCotter, executive director of the Utah Dept. of Corrections
Information regarding new inmate phone system Appeal denied
94-01 Karl William Winsness vs.
Salt Lake City Corporation
Police "no knock - no announce warrants," "high risk arrests and searches," and "major incident responses." Appeal denied
94-02 Julian Dean Hatch vs.
Utah State Div. of Parks and Recreation
Records regarding archeological digs and research done at Coombs site, Anasazi State Park Appeal denied
94-03 Salt Lake City vs.
Utah Dept. of Employment Security
Number of employees for each business Appeal granted
94-04 Deseret News vs.
University of Utah
Cold fusion licensing documents Appeal denied
94-05 Linda A. Watson vs.
Utah Dept. of Human Services,
Offices of Liability Management
Resolution Assistance Committee report regarding petitioner's minor children Appeal partially granted
94-06 Michael R. Weibel vs.
Logan City
Police report and city agreement Appeal partially granted
94-07 Linda A. Watson vs
Utah Dept. of Human Resources,
Division of Family Services
Records relating to petitioner's children Appeal denied
94-08 William Remine vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Policies, a list of inmates, and a list of staff Appeal partially granted
94-09 Sassy M. Fink and KSTU vs.
Utah State Hospital
Medical records and investigation records of an injury-causing incident Appeal partially granted
94-10 William Remine vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Records regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected." Appeal denied
94-11 William Remine vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Records of the Board of Pardons regarding Appellant that are classified as "protected." Appeal denied
94-12 Abigail W. Delfausse vs.
Utah State University
Appellant's personnel file classified "protected." Appeal granted
94-13 United Television Inc., a Delaware Corporation, aba KTVX Channel 4 vs.
Board of Pardons and Parole
Video tape regarding assault of Howard W. Hunter Appeal denied
94-14 Thomas R. Garcia vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Fee waiver for medical records Appeal granted
94-15 Linda A. Watson vs.
Utah Dept. of Human Services,
Division of Family Services
Two letters from Dr. Kevin Gully (a supervising therapist for minor children of petitioner) and a complete unredacted letter of a third party. Appeal denied
94-16 Salt Lake City vs.
Industrial Commission of Utah
Records relating to LaMar C. Macklin in the Matter of LaMar C. Macklin v. Salt Lake City Corporation before the UADD Appeal granted
94-17 Roger E. Penman vs.
Utah Dept. of Corrections
Supplemental Reports and Investigative Reports concerning a disciplinary case Appeal denied

Next Page